My Swing Vote


On Theologica, my recent haunt of many a high-octane discussion, there’s a thread regarding Christian voting and the abortion issue. The question is if the issue is so central that it will decide your vote. Well me, most definitely. I will always vote against anyone who not only supports abortion but also plans to expand on it. Does that make me religious right? I don’t think and here’s why.

In regards to the economy I’m really behind how the democrats managed to clean house on the budge. In regards to the war in Iraq, I’m against it and think that it’s an awful thing especially now that there really was no weapons publicly announced as being found. I do think that we can’t just pull out of there without causing a lot of problems down the road for the Iraqi’s and for the rest of the world so we should be in there for the long haul (but I’m gritting my teeth typing that).

In regards to gay marriage I don’t think that there should be a constitutional amendment rejecting it specifically because I don’t think the constitution should be legislating what’s a state level decision. By pushing a federal ruling that defines marriage as male and female it’s just as bad as a federal level decision that allows the killing of children.

Not only do I think an amendment is wrong but I think that constitutionally speaking it’s wrong to deny gay couples tax breaks that married couples get when the tax breaks being received is from living together in the same home: not by the definition of their relationship. That being the case, I don’t have a problem with siblings who don’t marry, living together and supporting each other and getting the same tax breaks married couples get. It’s a tough world and it really winds up not being fair when you can’t afford buying a house on your own anymore.

In regards to poverty I think the government on the state and federal level should be more active in fighting it. In regards to tax rates I think the rich either need to be taxed higher not to punish them but to invest in the community of the United States. In regards to business practices I think corporations have gone too far and they need tighter regulation. In regards to energy I think we need to invest in cleaner, renewable energy instead of being addicted to fossil fuels.

I pretty much sound like a democrat save this: I refuse to support a candidate who says that killing of a person is allowable when the parent has sole control of the person. I think that abortion is the worst atrocity being committed in our world today not merely because it’s the ending of life but because life is being redefined to not be human and thus dispensable.

When we can allow that we can allow anything. Eugenics becomes a no-issue: we can do whatever we want when we make it.

Here’s where I sound religious right: from a Biblical perspective I see each human being as a living creature made in the form, image, likeness of God. A person who grows into a murderer they’re in the form, image of likeness of God but they have marred themselves beyond recognition: they’ve become a cruel parody of God. A child killed in the womb is still a being in the form, likeness and image of God but has been extinguished before ever having a chance to express him or herself.

If a woman has had an abortion, I will of course quickly extend arms of comfort and mercy: I don’t think that the decision to do this sort of thing is easily made nor does it come without consequences. But that being said I don’t think that it should be a decision that has to be made when society provides the proper support structure to welcome new members.


6 responses to “My Swing Vote”

  1. I’m to the right of you on most of the issues you named. I’m left-leaning on the issues of immigration and the death penalty. But abortion is the litmus-test for me, too. I absolutely REFUSE to vote for a candidate who favors abortion on demand. If Rudy had been the GOP’s guy this election I’d not be voting for PotUS this November.

    I’m convinced that the abortion issue is to this age what the slavery issue was two hundred years ago. Some day people will look back and shake their heads with disgust that our society could justify the taking of human life in the name of convenience.

    I need to check Theologica more often, by the way. I joined, left a couple of comments, and then promptly forgot all about it.

  2. Yeah I don’t know what I would’ve done with Rudy on there and I’m completely with you on looking back two centuries from now (I hope, I so hope that it doesn’t get worst) and that we shake our heads in horror.

    Theologica’s been fun with the discussions. Some folk are a bit too convinced of always being right (coff*me*coff) but other than that, not too shabby.

    Dude, did I ever welcome you back and tell you that I’ve prayed for you guys?

  3. I was talking about this in a forum the other day… and although I don’t approve of abortion I wonder what your thoughts are if your loved one were raped and then told by the government that the baby must be brought to term. I believe a woman should always have the right to make a choice.

  4. Let me switch the illustration:

    Hitler’s Germany is Evil and invades the US
    US is intermingled and therefore Hawaii becomes owned by a German invaded country.
    US nukes Hawaii.

    Doesn’t make sense with abortion either:

    Person X does horrendous wrong to Person Y
    Person Y gets pregnant with Person Z
    Therefore Person Y gets to kill Person Z.

    Do you see the problem? The solution is not to attack and destroy the innocent third party no matter how they’re the progeny of X individual. The solution is Something Else: be it adoption, raising the child to abhor rape, raising the child via the family–something that is not murder.

  5. All true, Rey.

    And, besides, the number of abortions performed in cases of incest, rape and threat to the mother’s health is a TINY fraction of the whole. People always bring up cases of rape, incest and/or threat to the mother’s health … and I’m open to the point of view that those cases are valid reasons to consider abortion … but the fact is, the vast majority of abortions are performed because the baby was conceived by people who want to eliminate the baby they’ve conceived as a matter of convenience.

    Saying abortion should be legal because of rape, incest and/or threat to the mother’s health is like saying that killing people with handguns should be legal because of the instances where someone had no choice but to use a handgun to defend themselves and their family from attackers.